How to Resolve Fair Tenancy Disputes in Singapore

Disputes between landlords and tenants are an inevitable part of the leasing ecosystem, often arising from disagreements over lease terms, rental payments, or maintenance responsibilities. With the introduction of Singapore’s Fair Tenancy Framework, including the Code of Conduct for Leasing of Retail Premises, businesses now have access to structured and cost-effective dispute resolution mechanisms. This guide explores how these processes work and how both landlords and tenants can navigate fair tenancy disputes effectively.

1. Understanding the Fair Tenancy Framework

The Fair Tenancy Framework was established to promote transparency, reciprocity, and sustainability in landlord-tenant relationships. It includes guidelines for lease agreements, dispute resolution processes, and compliance monitoring.

1.1 The Code of Conduct for Leasing of Retail Premises

The Code sets out principles designed to ensure fair negotiations between landlords and tenants. It covers key areas such as:

• Transparent rent structures
• Clear maintenance responsibilities
• Security deposit limits (Rajah & Tann).

1.2 Dispute Resolution Framework

The framework mandates a two-step process—mediation followed by adjudication—to resolve disputes related to non-compliance with the Code (Singapore Mediation Centre).

2. Common Causes of Fair Tenancy Disputes

Understanding the common causes of disputes can help both parties take preventive measures:

• Ambiguous Lease Terms: Vague clauses on rent adjustments or termination rights often lead to conflicts (DollarsAndSense).
• Maintenance Responsibilities: Disagreements over who should bear the cost of repairs or upkeep are frequent sources of tension.
• Non-Compliance with Leasing Principles: Breaches of the Code, such as unclear rent formulas or unreasonable exclusivity clauses, can result in disputes (Today Online).

3. Steps to Resolve Fair Tenancy Disputes

Resolving disputes under Singapore’s fair tenancy framework involves a structured process:

3.1 Mediation: The First Step

Mediation is a collaborative approach where a neutral third party facilitates discussions between landlords and tenants to reach a mutually acceptable solution.

• How It Works: The Singapore Mediation Centre (SMC) appoints a Scheme Mediator to oversee discussions. Mediation is typically conducted online for up to 10 calendar days (Singapore Mediation Centre).
• Cost: Filing fees start at S$163.50 per party, with additional fees based on rental amounts.
• Benefits: Mediation is cost-effective, confidential, and preserves business relationships by fostering constructive dialogue.

3.2 Adjudication: When Mediation Fails

If mediation does not resolve the issue, either party can escalate the matter to adjudication.

• Process: An adjudicator reviews documents submitted by both parties and issues a binding decision within 14 days (Rajah & Tann).
• Outcomes: The adjudicator may order lease variations or compensation for non-compliance with leasing principles.
• Cost: Filing fees start at S$327 per party, with additional charges based on the complexity of the case.

3.3 Enforcement

Adjudication determinations can be enforced as court orders if necessary, ensuring compliance from both parties (Today Online).

4. Alternative Dispute Resolution Channels

In addition to mediation and adjudication under the fair tenancy framework, other avenues include:

4.1 Small Claims Tribunals (SCT)

For disputes involving sums up to S$20,000 (or S$30,000 with mutual consent), tenants and landlords can approach the SCT (99.co).

4.2 Community Mediation Centre (CMC)

The CMC offers low-cost mediation services for smaller disputes that do not require formal legal proceedings (Real Centre Network).

5. Preventive Measures for Avoiding Disputes

Preventing disputes is always better than resolving them. Both landlords and tenants should take proactive steps:

5.1 Draft Comprehensive Lease Agreements

Ensure lease agreements are detailed and compliant with the Code of Conduct (DollarsAndSense).

5.2 Maintain Open Communication

Regular check-ins between landlords and tenants can help address issues before they escalate into disputes (99.co).

5.3 Leverage Resources Like SGTUFF

Organizations like SGTUFF offer resources and training programs designed to help businesses understand their rights under the fair tenancy framework.

6. Benefits of Structured Dispute Resolution

The structured dispute resolution process under the fair tenancy framework offers several advantages:

6.1 Cost Efficiency

Mediation and adjudication are more affordable than traditional litigation, making them accessible for small businesses.

6.2 Time Savings

Disputes are resolved quickly—mediation takes up to 10 days, while adjudication decisions are issued within 14 days (Singapore Mediation Centre).

6.3 Preservation of Relationships

Collaborative approaches like mediation foster goodwill between landlords and tenants, ensuring long-term partnerships.

7. Conclusion

Resolving fair tenancy disputes in Singapore has become more straightforward with the introduction of structured processes like mediation and adjudication under the fair tenancy framework. By understanding these mechanisms and leveraging available resources, landlords and tenants can protect their interests while fostering a fair leasing environment.

---

Empowering Businesses with SGTUFF

At SGTUFF, we believe in creating a level playing field for businesses in Singapore. Whether you’re a tenant navigating leasing challenges or an SME striving for growth, we provide resources and insights to help you succeed.

Here’s how you can ge