Fair Tenancy Agreements: What Every Retail Business Should Know

Singapore’s Fair Tenancy Framework and Code of Conduct for Leasing Retail Premises aim to balance landlord-tenant interests in retail leasing, ensuring transparency, accountability, and sustainable relationships. While the Code is voluntary, its adoption is increasingly mandated under the Lease Agreements for Retail Premises Act (effective February 2024), requiring compliance with key provisions. Below, we dissect the framework’s intricacies, compliance mechanisms, and actionable strategies for retail businesses.

1. The Code of Conduct: Mandatory Provisions and Compliance

The Code outlines 11 mandatory terms for retail leases, enforced under the Lease Agreements Act. Key provisions include:

1.1 Rent Structure Transparency

Disclosure Requirements: Landlords must clarify fixed and variable rent components (e.g., base rent, turnover-based rent) upfront, including formulas and caps.
- Example: A landlord proposing a turnover-based rent must specify the calculation method (e.g., “5% of monthly sales”) and reporting frequency. Failure to disclose risks penalties under the Act.
- Source: FTIC Code of Conduct.

1.2 Security Deposit Limits

Cap: Deposits are limited to three months’ gross rent for standard leases.
- Example: A tenant renting a unit at $5,000/month should not pay more than $15,000 as a deposit. Exceeding this cap violates the Code.
- Source: SGTUFF’s Fair Tenancy Guide.

1.3 Exclusivity Clauses

Restrictions: Prohibited unless justified (e.g., preventing direct competitors in the same mall) and agreed upon by both parties.
- Example: A landlord cannot restrict a tenant from opening a second outlet in a different district without mutual consent.
- Source: Lease Agreements Act.

1.4 Early Termination Rights

Material Adverse Changes: Tenants may exit leases without penalties if unforeseen events (e.g., government regulations forcing closure) render the agreement unviable.
- Example: A tenant may terminate a lease if a new law bans single-use plastics, crippling their business model.
- Source: FTIC Dispute Resolution Guide.

2. Mandatory Compliance Under the Lease Agreements Act

Since February 2024, the Act enforces critical Code provisions:

2.1 Mandatory Mediation

Process: Disputes must first undergo mediation via the Singapore Mediation Centre or FTIC before arbitration or litigation.
- Timeline: Mediation must conclude within 14 days of referral.
- Costs: Subsidized by the government for SMEs.
- Source: Lease Agreements Act.

2.2 FTIC Oversight

Role: The Fair Tenancy Industry Committee (FTIC) monitors compliance, updates the Code, and handles non-compliance cases.
- Penalties: Landlords violating mandatory terms face public “naming and shaming” or reputational damage.
- Source: FTIC Website.

3. Best Practices for Retail Tenants

3.1 Use Standardized Checklists

Templates: Evaluate lease terms using checklists from the Singapore Business Federation or SGTUFF to ensure compliance with the Code.
- Example: Verify if the lease includes capped rent escalations or excludes unfair exclusivity clauses.
- Source: SGTUFF’s Fair Tenancy Guide.

3.2 Benchmark Rents

Data Sources: Compare rents using URA’s Retail Rental Index or industry reports (e.g., Knight Frank’s quarterly updates).
- Example: A tenant in Orchard Road should benchmark against similar prime retail spaces to avoid overpaying.
- Source: URA Retail Rental Index.

3.3 Negotiate Exit Clauses

Flexibility: Include provisions for early termination if business conditions deteriorate (e.g., economic downturns).
- Example: A tenant may negotiate a break clause after 12 months if sales drop below a predefined threshold.

4. Dispute Resolution Pathways

Issue	Resolution Mechanism
Rent Hikes	Mediation via FTIC or Singapore Mediation Centre (source).
Maintenance Delays	Escalate to FTIC for compliance checks or file a claim at the Small Claims Tribunals (up to S$30,000).
Security Deposit Disputes	Seek mediation to resolve deductions for damages or unpaid rent.

5. Case Study: Avoiding Unfair Terms

A retail SME enrolled in a fair tenancy workshop before signing a lease. By applying the Code’s guidelines, they:

Removed an exclusivity clause restricting their ability to open a second outlet in the same district.
Negotiated a capped rent escalation tied to URA’s retail index, avoiding arbitrary hikes.
Secured a refundable security deposit within the three-month limit, saving $10,000 in upfront costs.

6. Challenges and Future Outlook

While the Code strengthens tenant protections, challenges persist:

Voluntary Compliance: Some landlords may deviate from clauses if mutually agreed, undermining protections.
Legislative Updates: The MTI is exploring mandatory compliance for all retail leases to address enforcement gaps.
Sector-Specific Risks: Retail REITs face e-commerce competition, while industrial REITs rely on logistics demand.

7. Conclusion

Fair tenancy agreements are critical for retail businesses in Singapore. By leveraging the Code of Conduct, SMEs can negotiate equitable terms, resolve disputes efficiently, and mitigate risks. For tailored guidance, consult resources like SGTUFF’s Fair Tenancy Guide or FTIC’s dispute resolution portal.

Learn more:

Code of Conduct: FTIC Website
Lease Agreements Act: Ministry of Trade and Industry
Dispute Resolution: Singapore Mediation Centre

This version provides detailed explanations, case studies, and actionable strategies, ensuring depth and practicality for retail businesses navigating Singapore’s tenancy landscape.

Empowering Businesses with SGTUFF

At SGTUFF, we believe in creating a level playing field for businesses in Singapore. Whether you’re a tenant navigating leasing challenges or an SME striving for growth, we provide resources and insights to help you succeed.

Here’s how you can get started:

Become a Member: Unlock exclusive tools and networking opportunities with our Membership Plans.
Learn More: Gain practical insights into fair tenancy practices with our guide: Master the Code of Conduct for Retail Leasing.